Schulich logo The word Schulich Schulich Wordmark The word Schulich with the words Leading Change Schulich Logo The Schulich logo Schulich 50th Logo The number 50 Search An icon depicting a magnifying glass Envelope An icon depicting an envelope Phone An icon depicting a phone Fax An icon depicting a fax machine Map Pin An icon depicting a map pin People An icon depicting two people Graduation Cap An icon depicting a graduation cap Menu An icon depicting three lines Close An icon depicting an X Arrow Up An icon depicting an upward facing arrow Arrow Right An icon depicting a right facing arrow Arrow Down An icon depicting a downward facing arrow Arrow Left An icon depicting a left facing arrow Plus An icon depicting a plus sign Minus An icon depicting a minus sign Chart An icon depicting a chart Book An icon depicting a book Envelope An icon depicting a stamped envelope Dollar Sign An icon depicting a dollar sign Briefcase An icon depicting a briefcase Page An icon depicting a single page Share An icon depicting three connected dots Alert An icon depicting a triangle with an exclamation point Calendar An icon depicting a blank calendar Event An icon depicting a blank calendar Add Event An icon depicting a calendar with a plus sign on it Event Details An icon depicting a calendar with a question mark on it Print An icon depicting a printer Comment An icon depicting a speech bubble Feed The RSS icon Details An icon depicting a page with three lines of text Facebook An icon depicting the Facebook logo Twitter An icon depicting the Twitter logo YouTube An icon depicting the YouTube logo LinkedIn An icon depicting the LinkedIn logo Instagram An icon depicting the Instagram logo Long Arrow Left An icon depicting an arrow pointing left Long Arrow Down An icon depicting an arrow pointing down Flexible Study Options An icon depicting a branching line Awards An icon depicting a ribbon Advisory Board An icon depicting a round table Graduate Diploma An icon depicting a graduation cap Professional Designations An icon depicting a certificate Academics An icon depicting an academic building Schulich Logo The Schulich logo Academics An icon depicting an academic building Globe An icon depicting the globe with an arrow circling it Globe An icon depicting the globe with an arrow circling it Award Ribbon An icon depicting a ribbon Teacher An icon depicting a teacher pointing at a blackboard Double Location An icon depicting two location pins Wireframe Globe An icon depicting a wireframe globe Airplane An icon depicting an airplane Play Icon in the shape of a play button as found on videos Full-time Icon representing a full-time program Part-time Icon representing a part-time program Full-time Accelerated Icon representing a full-time accelerated program Part-time Accelerated Icon representing a part-time accelerated program Program Details Icon representing program details Program Tuition Icon representing tuition and fees Career Opportunities Icon representing program details Accreditations Icon representing program accreditations Program Options Icon representing program options Requirements Icon representing program requirements Courses and Electives Icon representing program courses Faculty Icon representing program faculty Clubs Icon representing program clubs Courthouse Icon representing a courthouse Oil Icon representing an oil droplet Retail Icon representing a shopping bag Food Icon representing a fork and knife Construction Icon representing a hammer and wrench Person A silhouette of a person Person An outline of a person Folder An outline of a folder Pie chart An outline of a pie chart Graph An outline of a bar graph Save An arrow pointing into a box Play An outline of a play arrow Key An outline of a key Ticket An outline of a ticket Books Two books Computer A laptop computer Globe An outline of a globe Plane An outline of a plane Accelerated Program An outline of a fast-forward button Part-time Program An arrow arcing around a clock Viewbook An outline of an open book Medal A medal with a star Professor A lecturing professor Suit A person wearing a suit Laptop Laptop computer (by FlatIcon) Locked Closed Access Unlocked Open Access Google Scholar Google Scholar icon Calendar An icon depicting a blank calendar India An icon depicting a Indian landmark Report An icon depicting a briefcase Skip to content

Key to retaining women in the workplace lies in fair processes, not just fair outcomes, study finds

  • Future Students
  • Current Students
    Undergraduate Students ›Graduate Students ›PhD Students ›
     › › › ›
  • Alumni
    • Mentorship & Volunteering ›

      Alumni Benefits ›

      Success Stories ›

      Common Questions ›

      Contact Alumni Relations ›

    • Alumni Events ›

      Global Alumni Chapters ›

      Alumni Services for Students ›

      Alumni Recognition Awards ›

    Overview ›Alumni Career Portal ›Online Community ›
     › › › ›
  • Donors
    • Ways to Support ›

      The Impact of Giving ›

      Sponsorship Opportunities ›

      Leaving a Legacy to Schulich ›

      Contact Development Office ›

    • Schulich Priorities ›

      The Schulich Annual Fund ›

      The Dean’s Society ›

      Tribute Giving ›

    Overview ›Donate Now ›
     › › › ›
  • Recruiters
  • Media
MySchulich
Schulich School of Business
  • Future Students
  • Current Students
    Undergraduate Students ›Graduate Students ›PhD Students ›
     › › › ›
  • Alumni
    • Mentorship & Volunteering ›

      Alumni Benefits ›

      Success Stories ›

      Common Questions ›

      Contact Alumni Relations ›

    • Alumni Events ›

      Global Alumni Chapters ›

      Alumni Services for Students ›

      Alumni Recognition Awards ›

    Overview ›Alumni Career Portal ›Online Community ›
     › › › ›
  • Donors
    • Ways to Support ›

      The Impact of Giving ›

      Sponsorship Opportunities ›

      Leaving a Legacy to Schulich ›

      Contact Development Office ›

    • Schulich Priorities ›

      The Schulich Annual Fund ›

      The Dean’s Society ›

      Tribute Giving ›

    Overview ›Donate Now ›
     › › › ›
  • Recruiters
  • Media
  • Programs
    & Courses
    • Undergraduate

      BBA ›

      Master of Business Administration

      MBA ›
      MBA / Juris Doctor ›
      MBA / MFA / MA ›
      Kellogg-Schulich Executive MBA ›
      Tech MBA ›

    • Specialized Masters Programs

      Accounting ›
      Artificial Intelligence ›
      Business Analytics ›
      Finance ›
      Health Industry Administration ›
      Management ›
      Marketing ›
      Real Estate & Infrastructure ›
      Supply Chain Management ›

    • Exchange

      Incoming Exchange and Programs ›

      Graduate Diplomas

      Post-MBA Diploma in Advanced Management ›
      Accounting Analytics ›

      Doctor of Philosophy

      PhD in Administration ›

     › › › ›
  • Admissions
    • Undergraduate

      Apply Now ›
      Admissions FAQs ›
      Connect With Us ›
      Admission Events ›
      Meet the Team ›

    • Graduate

      Apply Now ›

      Tuition Fees & Costs ›

      Application Tips ›

      Connect with Us ›

      Admission Events ›

      Meet the Team ›

    Admissions Requirements ›
     › › › ›
  • Faculty
    & Research
  • Student Life
    & Services
    • Case Competition Program ›
      Centre for Career Design ›
      Event Calendar ›
      Financial Aid ›

    • International Relations ›
      Libraries ›
      Services for Students ›
      Student Life at Schulich ›

     › › › ›
  • About
    • Our Dean ›

      Rankings ›

      Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion ›

      Case Competition Program ›

      Schulich Startups ›

      Impact Report ›

      News & Events ›

      Contact Directory ›

    • Our Heritage ›

      Recruit at Schulich ›

      Work at Schulich ›

      Hospitality & Hotel Services ›

    Learn more about Schulich ›
     › › › ›
  • Executive
    MBA
    • Program Information

      Overview ›

      Program Details ›

      Schedule & Courses ›

    • Admission Requirements ›

      Tuition Fees ›

      Follow us on LinkedIn ›

    Are you EMBA ready? ›Request a pre-assessment ›

     

    Contact us at 416-736-5486 or emba@schulich.yorku.ca​

     › › › ›
  • Executive
    Education
  • MySchulich

About

About › News & Events

  • ‹ News Feed
  • March 28, 2016

    Key to retaining women in the workplace lies in fair processes, not just fair outcomes, study finds

    TORONTO – Monday, March 28, 2016 – Managers trying to retain valued female employees should be aware that women are more strongly affected by the process used to achieve workplace equity than the actual outcome, finds a new study from the Schulich School of Business.

    That’s because women tend to care more about the aspects of a fair process that let a person feel they can participate in and have some control over important decisions that affect them, according to the study published in the Journal of Managerial Psychology.

    The study, “Organizational powerlessness, dehumanization, and gendered effects of procedural justice”, is important because the researchers found that procedural justice and related feelings of control have an impact on women’s stated intention to change jobs, and so directly influences staff turnover.

    “Paradoxically, women may be more concerned about the process being fair than about the outcome,” said Chris Bell, lead author of the study and Associate Professor of Organization Studies at Schulich.  “To reduce staff turnover, managers and organizations should be aware of the different gendered needs of their employees and the different impact that may be based on the way in which decisions about equity and justice are arrived at and communicated.”

    “At the same time, women should be aware of this gendered difference so they can be diligent in assessing justice and their response to being treated fairly,” said Bell.

    Bell conducted the research with Careen Khoury, a PhD student with the Social Psychology Department at York University. The researchers recruited men and women to participate in a two-wave survey of workplace attitudes by distributing flyers at subway exits in downtown Toronto. The authors controlled for and tested alternative models for distributive and interpersonal justice.

    Most research on gender differences and responses to fairness has been based in the stereotype that women care more about relationships than men, said Bell.

    “We took as our starting point the assumption that women may be confident in their own abilities but may also be aware of the widespread inequities in workplace outcomes, and so may have concerns that their outcomes can be controlled by others,” said Bell. “Procedural fairness directly addresses these kinds of concerns.”

    Managers may feel no need to intervene if some workers receive a higher bonus than their co-workers, as long as the manager perceives the bonus distribution to be fair. However, this research suggests that it is especially important to communicate to women that workplace bonuses are arrived at through a just process than it is to distribute bonuses of fair amounts. The research suggests that female employees will be more accepting of a bonus distribution that is arrived at through a procedurally fair manner, even if their own bonus is less than what they would like.

    The finding rests on a complex mediation of a procedural justice effect on organizational powerlessness and dehumanization in the workplace, that in turn is related to turnover intentions.  Research and lay theories have emphasized that women value procedural justice because of inherently stronger relational needs. The findings of this study suggest gendered effects are due to broader social conditions affecting women’s instrumental and existential needs, or more particularly their need to feel control over their lives in an inequitable and so unpredictable world.

    Most importantly, the finding is not related to innate gender differences but to endemic social inequities, the researchers say. Procedural justice is associated with basic human needs and the gendered effects in the study may be socially constructed.

    The study has just been published in Journal of Managerial Psychology and may be accessed online at: http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/full/10.1108/JMP-09-2014-0267

    About Schulich

    Known as Canada’s Global Business School™, the Schulich School of Business in Toronto is ranked among the world’s leading business schools by a number of global surveys. Schulich’s MBA program is ranked #1 in the world by Corporate Knights, the world’s largest circulation magazine with an explicit focus on Corporate Social Responsibility, in a global survey that identifies which schools are doing the best job of preparing future business leaders for the environmental, social and ethical complexities of modern-day business. Schulich’s MBA program is also ranked #1 in Canada and among the world’s leading schools by The Economist, Forbes and CNN Expansión. The Kellogg-Schulich EMBA program is ranked #5 in the world by The Economist and #1 in Canada by the Financial Times of London. For complete ranking details, please visit www.schulich.yorku.ca.

    Global, innovative and diverse, Schulich offers business programs year-round at its state-of-the-art complex at York University; at its Miles S. Nadal Management Centre located in the heart of the Toronto’s financial district; and at its new campus in Hyderabad, India. Schulich also operates a number of satellite centres in Beijing and Shanghai, China; Mumbai, India; Seoul, South Korea; Mexico City, Mexico; and Sao Paulo, Brazil. Schulich offers undergraduate, graduate and postgraduate business degrees that lead to rewarding careers in the private, public and nonprofit sectors, and has 27,000 alumni working in over 90 countries. The School pioneered Canada’s first International MBA (IMBA) and International BBA (iBBA) degrees, as well as North America’s first ever cross-border Executive MBA degree, the Kellogg-Schulich Executive MBA. In addition to Schulich’s Master of Finance and Master of Accounting degrees, the School launched one of the world’s first Master of Business Analytics degrees. Schulich’s Executive Education Centre provides executive development programs annually to more than 10,000 executives in Canada and abroad.

     

    For more information, please contact:

    Beth Marlin, Media Relations and Public Relations

    Schulich School of Business

    Email: bmarlin@schulich.yorku.ca

    Phone: 905-717-6278

    Please follow us on Twitter @SchulichNews

  • Related Posts

    Uncategorized ›
  • Schulich - York University
    • Directions
    • Location Inquiries
    • Contact Directory
    • Event Calendar
    • MySchulich
  • Information for:

    • Future Students
    • Current Students Undergraduate
    • Current Students Graduate
    • Current PHD Students
    • Alumni
    • Donors
    • Recruiters
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Media
  • Go to:

    • About
    • Admissions
    • Faculty Listing
    • Student Life at Schulich
    • Services for Students
    • Wellness Suite
    • Privacy
    • Site Map
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

© Copyright 2025 The Schulich School of Business, York University.