Schulich logo The word Schulich Schulich Wordmark The word Schulich with the words Leading Change Schulich Logo The Schulich logo Schulich 50th Logo The number 50 Search An icon depicting a magnifying glass Envelope An icon depicting an envelope Phone An icon depicting a phone Fax An icon depicting a fax machine Map Pin An icon depicting a map pin People An icon depicting two people Graduation Cap An icon depicting a graduation cap Menu An icon depicting three lines Close An icon depicting an X Arrow Up An icon depicting an upward facing arrow Arrow Right An icon depicting a right facing arrow Arrow Down An icon depicting a downward facing arrow Arrow Left An icon depicting a left facing arrow Plus An icon depicting a plus sign Minus An icon depicting a minus sign Chart An icon depicting a chart Book An icon depicting a book Envelope An icon depicting a stamped envelope Dollar Sign An icon depicting a dollar sign Briefcase An icon depicting a briefcase Page An icon depicting a single page Share An icon depicting three connected dots Alert An icon depicting a triangle with an exclamation point Calendar An icon depicting a blank calendar Event An icon depicting a blank calendar Add Event An icon depicting a calendar with a plus sign on it Event Details An icon depicting a calendar with a question mark on it Print An icon depicting a printer Comment An icon depicting a speech bubble Feed The RSS icon Details An icon depicting a page with three lines of text Facebook An icon depicting the Facebook logo Twitter An icon depicting the Twitter logo YouTube An icon depicting the YouTube logo LinkedIn An icon depicting the LinkedIn logo Instagram An icon depicting the Instagram logo Long Arrow Left An icon depicting an arrow pointing left Long Arrow Down An icon depicting an arrow pointing down Flexible Study Options An icon depicting a branching line Awards An icon depicting a ribbon Advisory Board An icon depicting a round table Graduate Diploma An icon depicting a graduation cap Professional Designations An icon depicting a certificate Academics An icon depicting an academic building Schulich Logo The Schulich logo Academics An icon depicting an academic building Globe An icon depicting the globe with an arrow circling it Globe An icon depicting the globe with an arrow circling it Award Ribbon An icon depicting a ribbon Teacher An icon depicting a teacher pointing at a blackboard Double Location An icon depicting two location pins Wireframe Globe An icon depicting a wireframe globe Airplane An icon depicting an airplane Play Icon in the shape of a play button as found on videos Full-time Icon representing a full-time program Part-time Icon representing a part-time program Full-time Accelerated Icon representing a full-time accelerated program Part-time Accelerated Icon representing a part-time accelerated program Program Details Icon representing program details Program Tuition Icon representing tuition and fees Career Opportunities Icon representing program details Accreditations Icon representing program accreditations Program Options Icon representing program options Requirements Icon representing program requirements Courses and Electives Icon representing program courses Faculty Icon representing program faculty Clubs Icon representing program clubs Courthouse Icon representing a courthouse Oil Icon representing an oil droplet Retail Icon representing a shopping bag Food Icon representing a fork and knife Construction Icon representing a hammer and wrench Person A silhouette of a person Person An outline of a person Folder An outline of a folder Pie chart An outline of a pie chart Graph An outline of a bar graph Save An arrow pointing into a box Play An outline of a play arrow Key An outline of a key Ticket An outline of a ticket Books Two books Computer A laptop computer Globe An outline of a globe Plane An outline of a plane Accelerated Program An outline of a fast-forward button Part-time Program An arrow arcing around a clock Viewbook An outline of an open book Medal A medal with a star Professor A lecturing professor Suit A person wearing a suit Laptop Laptop computer (by FlatIcon) Locked Closed Access Unlocked Open Access Google Scholar Google Scholar icon Calendar An icon depicting a blank calendar India An icon depicting a Indian landmark Report An icon depicting a briefcase Skip to content

AM&E Adjunct Professor Doug Barrett: Foreign streamers and CANCON

  • Future Students
  • Current Students
    Undergraduate Students ›Graduate Students ›PhD Students ›
     › › › ›
  • Alumni
    • Mentorship & Volunteering ›

      Alumni Benefits ›

      Success Stories ›

      Common Questions ›

      Contact Alumni Relations ›

    • Alumni Events ›

      Global Alumni Chapters ›

      Alumni Services for Students ›

      Alumni Recognition Awards ›

    Overview ›Alumni Career Portal ›Online Community ›
     › › › ›
  • Donors
    • Ways to Support ›

      The Impact of Giving ›

      Sponsorship Opportunities ›

      Leaving a Legacy to Schulich ›

      Contact Development Office ›

    • Schulich Priorities ›

      The Schulich Annual Fund ›

      The Dean’s Society ›

      Tribute Giving ›

    Overview ›Donate Now ›
     › › › ›
  • Recruiters
  • Media
MySchulich
Schulich School of Business
  • Future Students
  • Current Students
    Undergraduate Students ›Graduate Students ›PhD Students ›
     › › › ›
  • Alumni
    • Mentorship & Volunteering ›

      Alumni Benefits ›

      Success Stories ›

      Common Questions ›

      Contact Alumni Relations ›

    • Alumni Events ›

      Global Alumni Chapters ›

      Alumni Services for Students ›

      Alumni Recognition Awards ›

    Overview ›Alumni Career Portal ›Online Community ›
     › › › ›
  • Donors
    • Ways to Support ›

      The Impact of Giving ›

      Sponsorship Opportunities ›

      Leaving a Legacy to Schulich ›

      Contact Development Office ›

    • Schulich Priorities ›

      The Schulich Annual Fund ›

      The Dean’s Society ›

      Tribute Giving ›

    Overview ›Donate Now ›
     › › › ›
  • Recruiters
  • Media
  • Programs
    & Courses
    • Program Finder ›
    • 5-Minute Suitability Questionnaire ›
    • Undergraduate

      BBA ›
      iBBA ›

      Master of Business Administration

      MBA ›
      MBA in India ›
      MBA / Juris Doctor ›
      MBA / MFA / MA ›
      Kellogg-Schulich Executive MBA ›

    • Specialized Masters Programs

      Accounting ›
      Artificial Intelligence ›
      Business Analytics ›
      Finance ›
      Health Industry Administration ›
      Management ›
      Marketing ›
      Real Estate & Infrastructure ›
      Supply Chain Management ›

    • Exchange

      Incoming Exchange and Programs ›

      Graduate Diplomas

      Post-MBA Diploma in Advanced Management ›
      Intermediate Accounting ›

      Doctor of Philosophy

      PhD in Administration ›

     › › › ›
  • Admissions
    • Undergraduate

      Apply Now ›
      Admissions FAQs ›
      Connect With Us ›
      Meet the Team ›

    • Graduate

      Apply Now ›

      Tuition Fees & Costs ›

      Application Tips ›

      Connect with Us ›

      Admission Events ›

      Meet the Team ›

    Admissions Requirements ›
     › › › ›
  • Faculty
    & Research
  • Student Life
    & Services
    • Case Competition Program ›
      Centre for Career Design ›
      Event Calendar ›
      Financial Aid ›

    • International Relations ›
      Libraries ›
      Services for Students ›
      Student Life at Schulich ›

     › › › ›
  • About
    • Our Dean ›

      Rankings ›

      Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion ›

      Case Competition Program ›

      Schulich Startups ›

      Year-End Report ›

      News & Events ›

      Contact Directory ›

    • Our Heritage ›

      Recruit at Schulich ›

      Work at Schulich ›

      Hospitality & Hotel Services ›

    Learn more about Schulich ›
     › › › ›
  • Executive
    MBA
    • Program Information

      Overview ›

      Program Details ›

      Schedule & Courses ›

    • Admission Requirements ›

      Tuition Fees ›

    Are you EMBA ready? ›Request a pre-assessment ›

     

    Contact us at 416-736-5486 or emba@schulich.yorku.ca​

     › › › ›
  • Executive
    Education
  • MySchulich

About

About › News & Events

  • ‹ News Feed
  • June 30, 2021

    AM&E Adjunct Professor Doug Barrett: Foreign streamers and CANCON

    from CARTT.CA 

    May 26, 2021 

    ANALYSIS: How foreign streamers might come to pick, and own, our Cancon 

    By Doug Barrett

    NETFLIX’S RECENT ANNOUNCEMENT that it would establish its Canadian  headquarters in Toronto produced considerable excitement – at least in Toronto.

    In February, under the heading “making a New Home in Canada”, Netflix’s Chief Content Officer, Ted Sarandos wrote a blog post announcing: “We want  to make a new home for Netflix in Canada – opening an office and hiring a dedicated content executive to work directly with the Canadian creative community.”

    Then in late April, the company announced Toronto had been selected as “Netflix’s 22nd international outpost” and Sarandos, in the press release, stated: “We’re looking forward to opening our doors and building on the great work we’ve started with our creative partners to bring more Canadian artists and stories to the world.

    Calling the Canada headquarters “a big first step,” Sarandos told Canadian Press it won’t be “one person in a little office in one city, in one place in Canada. We’re looking to grow our relationship with the creative community in  Canada. So that’ll be as open geographically as Canada is.”

    No wonder there is so much excitement. But what does all this actually mean for production in Canada? There are doubtless opportunities, but also grave dangers. Resolving the challenges in the best interests of Canada will require  we unweave a tangled web. This is complex stuff.

    On the positive side, Netflix and its competitors, such as Amazon Prime Video, have definitely made a huge contribution to the location service production industry. Service productions are valuable—they create lots of jobs. What they don’t create though, is exports, since Canadians don’t own the underlying intellectual property. Nor do they embody Canadian values,
    either for Canadians domestically, or for export to a world which desperately could use some Canadian values.

    Ironically, when then Heritage Minister Melanie Joly announced her “deal” with  Netflix in September of 2017, she seemed to infer that the promised $500 million spend over five years would be on Canadian content programming. “There’s no need for Netflix to open a Canadian production company in Canada just to do service production,” Joly said at the time.

    Since then, according to Profile 2020, the CMPA’s annual economic report on  the production industry published just last week, the amount of service production in Canada has almost doubled (from $2.64 billion to $5.25 billion) while the amount of Canadian content production has stagnated at around $3  billion per year. When Netflix publicizes its Canadian spend, it does not segregate out service production from Canadian production – so one must assume it’s all service.

    There are lots of examples of foreign location and service productions making  extensive use of Canadian creative talent. A recent example was Tiny Pretty Things produced by Insurrection Media, a Beverly Hills based company, and Peacock Alley Entertainment, a Toronto based production company. The series was entirely shot in Toronto, and entirely set in Chicago. Global rights
    are owned by Netflix. Was this what Minister Joly had in mind when she made  her deal (the details of which have never been published)?

    Canada remains a global leader on the service side of things thanks to the favourable currency, access to tax credits, physical proximity to the U.S., widespread availability of high quality crews, fantastic locations, studio infrastructure and outstanding creative talent. All of that contributes to an extremely attractive package. Netflix can produce and own the shows that are  made this way. And it’s all very good.

    The problem is that Netflix can also produce and own Canadian shows, and seems prepared to start doing so.

    A recent piece in the Wall Street Journal pointed to a dramatic departure in the approach now being taken by the major streamers, following Netflix’s lead,  towards foreign markets.

    Instead of the traditional approach in which Hollywood exported American films and TV shows with dubbing and subtitling for the target market, the streamers are now collectively investing billions of dollars to make local language content that is culturally specific to those markets.

    In a startling development, Netflix’s most recent quarterly report revealed that  fully 89% of its nearly four million new customers in the quarter came from “outside the U.S. and Canada”. In addition, Netflix’s most watched new series  during the quarter was the French-language series Lupin. Mr. Sarandos is quoted as saying of Lupin: “The show was not like a watered-down French
    show; it was a very French show.

    “The more authentically local they are, the more likely they are to play around  the world,” he added. And tellingly, “we started launching in international territories with no original programming in local language with local producers.  Now we are producing in most corners of the world.” As an example, Netflix recently announced it would invest $500 million in local language South
    Korean content.

    The WSJ article further reports that about half of Netflix’s new productions are  based outside the U.S.. Roughly 38% is non-English language content.

    While Disney+ and Amazon Prime Video are statistically behind in this category, growth is rapid. For its part, Prime Video reports its volume of original, local language content has doubled each year since 2017. And just this week Playback  ran an interview with Christina Wayne, the new head of Prime Video’s Canadian Originals, outlining its strategy for Canadian content.  Wayne is based in Toronto and reports to the international head of local originals, based in New York.

    This local market strategy has already arrived in Quebec. In its February Bill C-10 submission to the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, Netflix stated:

    “There are many examples of titles on Netflix that meet six or more CAVCO key creative requirements that cannot be certified as Cancon because the projects are financed exclusively by Netflix. Jusqu’au Déclin, shot in the Laurentians with its all-Quebec cast and crew, resulted in $5.8 million in direct  investment in the Province of Quebec. The film was viewed by over 21 million  subscribers in the first four weeks of its release to global audiences.”

    And of course, Netflix told the committee it would like to see amendments made to Bill C-10 that would require a “revisit” of how Canadian programming  is defined for regulatory purposes. We can surely expect that Netflix will ask that programs developed and produced by Canadian creators, but owned by Silicon Valley tech companies, will count as fully Canadian.

    In English Canada, similar developments are emerging. Sarandos’s statement  that the purpose of hiring a content executive is to work with creative partners  to bring Canadian stories to the world falls into line with the local content country strategies referred to in the WSJ article. In this context, Lupin becomes the streamer prototype for presenting Canadian stories.

    It’s fascinating to me that Sarandos is careful to mention Canadian artists and  creators each time he speaks of partnership – as well he should. What he never seems to mention though is anything about Canadian producers – and it doesn’t take too much to figure out that this is because Netflix itself will effectively be doing the producing and will likely own the resulting programs outright.

    For their part, Canadian producers report that while Netflix is often responsive  to their pitches and is prepared to front the production costs; what it wants in return is all rights – more or less indefinitely.

    Such deals simply make the Canadian producer who creates, develops, produces and builds the value of Canadian intellectual property into a service  producer – an employed producer for hire.

    Right now, Canadian content certification requires a Canadian producer, Canadian distribution rights ownership, and Canadian copyright ownership. What happens if certification is also available to a Silicon Valley streamer that  effectively owns shows that have been green lit by one of its commonwealth of 22 “international outposts”?

    One thinks here of a Faustian bargain, a pact where something of supreme moral or spiritual importance, such as personal values or the soul, is traded for a material benefit. To me, the analogy to the evolving Netflix/Prime Video local content country strategy (we choose your stories and we own them) seems uncomfortably apt.

    All this to say, how we resolve this so that Canadian stories are fully told and  owned by Canadians will be tricky indeed.

     

     

  • Related Posts

    Arts and Media ›
  • Schulich - York University
    • Directions
    • Location Inquiries
    • Contact Directory
    • Event Calendar
    • MySchulich
  • Information for:

    • Future Students
    • Current Students Undergraduate
    • Current Students Graduate
    • Alumni
    • Donors
    • Recruiters
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Media
  • Go to:

    • About
    • Admissions
    • Faculty Listing
    • Student Life at Schulich
    • Services for Students
    • Wellness Suite
    • Privacy
    • Site Map
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

© Copyright 2023 The Schulich School of Business, York University.